book club

George: Discussion

Another awesome read from this book club! Our final book for Page turners was George
by Alex Gino. Although George isn’t a true story, I know it’s true to many children and adults in this world. George is a great children’s book to teach acceptance in others and I’m so thankful more books like this are being published. Did you get a chance to read it? I gave it a 5/5 stars. I’ve got 3 questions below, and Lisa’s got 3 as well over on her blog. Feel free to discuss any or all of the questions in the comment section or link-up your post at the bottom. Lisa and I are sharing the same link-up, so you don’t have to enter on both blogs. The linky will close in a week. Alright, let’s get started!

George by Alex Gino

George is a very fast read as it is meant for children but it has a big story. It was definitely written for kids but I loved the detail to the book’s environment. I hope this book or a similar story is made into a movie. The struggle of gender equality, gender awareness and gender acceptance is much better now than it has been in the past but it is still a problem throughout the world.

And now, for the discussion. Before I begin, I’ll remind you that there may be spoilers ahead. Also, feel free to use my questions as jumping points. Ask your own questions and start your own discussions.

George by Alex GinoGeorge: Discussion

1.  Who was your favorite character? My favorite character was Kelly. The relationship between her and Melissa was so pure. Sweet, strong, and silly all at once—just as friendships between little girls should be. I loved that the author had Kelly think for a little while about her best friend’s news before she fully accepted her. Her love and respect for her father is also really endearing and makes me happy that such little girls exist in this world.

2. What did you think about the teacher’s reactions in this book? I was frustrated but not surprised by Mrs. Udell’s reaction when George tried out for the part of Charlotte. She had a right to be confused and caught off guard but not to completely discount her as someone trying out for the role. In my opinion, she should have let George try out for the part and if she had issues with him playing a ‘girls’ role, she should have kept that to herself. I loved that the principal stood up for George and having an open door for her to feel welcome. 

3. I loved this quote from Muggle Net: George may not only help guide such children to a place of self-esteem and acceptance but also help their peers (and teachers!) be more compassionate allies. Do you think it would be a good idea to have this book in the classroom? 100% yes. Children need to know what transgender is so that children like Melissa are able to identify the struggle they may not know how to name. My hope is that by the time Sophie is in elementary school, children are able to try out for whatever gender role they please in a school play.
I hope you’ve enjoyed reading along with us this year! Lisa and I will continue to read but are not able to keep up with Page Turners any longer. With us working on our new house and the holidays ahead, I hardly have time to read the books I must read, let alone for pleasure. If you do read any particularly great books, please let me know!

Now, it’s your turn! Answer any or all of the questions in the comment section below. Ask questions of your own. Or, link-up a blog post with your review and/or the answers to these questions. Also be sure to check out Lisa’s discussion questions on her blog. We’re sharing the same linky, so no need to link-up on both blogs.

page-turners2

 **This post contains affiliate links to books mentioned above.
For more book club suggestions, check out Shelly’s Pinterest board:


Silver Linings Playbook (Discussion)

Another awesome read from this book club! I really enjoyed the movie Silver Linings Playbook and was not disappointed by the book. Many times in the past, I’ve been disappointed by the book if I’ve watched the movie first. I think the adaptation of the book to movie was done wonderfully and the actors were spot on.  Did you get a chance to read it? I gave it a 5/5 stars. I’ve got 3 questions below, and Lisa’s got 3 as well over on her blog. Feel free to discuss any or all of the questions in the comment section or link-up your post at the bottom. Lisa and I are sharing the same link-up, so you don’t have to enter on both blogs. The linky will close in a week. Alright, let’s get started!

Silver Linings Playbook

I loved the connection I had with the main character, Pat. Although I’m not a mentally unstable person (some may doubt me here) I really connected with Pat’s feelings and struggles when he would have his outbursts. Having watched the movie first saved me from being too emotionally distraught over the course of the book but I was still deeply involved with the characters feelings. 

And now, for the discussion. Before I begin, I’ll remind you that there may be spoilers ahead. Also, feel free to use my questions as jumping points. Ask your own questions and start your own discussions.

Silver Linings Playbook- Page Turners Book Club

1.  Were there any characters you had a hard time relating to? I was extremely frustrated with Pat’s Dad. I found myself getting the most upset by his actions (or lack there of.) Matthew (the author) mentioned several times how ‘people can’t change’ but people do change. Pat’s Mom changed in not wanting to put up with his disinterest and I think there has to be some kind of meeting of middle ground if you don’t want to hurt the people you love. I can understand his resentment and frustration with Pat but not to the extent of which he lived.

2. Where you surprised when you found out Tiffany wrote the letters from ‘Nikki’? I was furious at Tiffany. Like Pat, I couldn’t understand her betrayal. I know she is also mentally unstable, and once she explained herself, I softened to her side of the story, but was initially extremely upset. Tiffany should not have followed through with the letter fiasco knowing that Pat was so deeply tied to the thought of ending ‘apart time’ with Nikki.

3. Pat practices being kind rather than being right. What do you think of this mantra? Are ‘being kind’ and ‘being right’ mutually exclusive? This mantra was my favorite part of the entire book. I loved Pat’s heart when he would practice this mantra. It’s an extremely difficult mantra to follow and we would all be better for working on it. I don’t think ‘being kind’ and ‘being right’ are mutually exclusive. Many times you can be both, but more often, they are not the same. I think Pat working on this mantra made him much more open to the people in his life and helped him learn to deal with his aggression. Some might think of it as passive but I think of it as peaceful.

Now, it’s your turn! Answer any or all of the questions in the comment section below. Ask questions of your own. Or, link-up a blog post with your review and/or the answers to these questions. Also be sure to check out Lisa’s discussion questions on her blog. We’re sharing the same linky, so no need to link-up on both blogs.

Remember, our final book will be in October: George by Alex Gino. I’m really looking forward to this next read! Please, join us. We’ll be discussing George on October 29th.

page-turners2

Follow Shelly @ DIY Mama’s board Book Club on Pinterest.

Page Turners Selection: October

Lisa and I are so happy to announce our book for October! It’s special because it’s the first new release we’ve selected (published August 25th) and it’s going to be our last book club selection. We’ve loved hosting our Page Turners book club but we’re both having a hard time keeping up with the books right now. With so many projects with the new house, spending more time with family and vacations I’m finding it hard to read even one book per month. So, we hope you’ll join us  for our final book this October:

George by Alex Gino

George by Alex Gino

Lisa first heard about George (Goodreads) on the Book Riot Podcast. It’s a book written for kids, and it’s about a boy named George who knows he’s really a girl. George wants to be Charlotte in his (her) school’s production of Charlotte’s Web but her teacher says no because she’s a boy. Well, shenanigans probably ensue so that she can let everyone who she is.George by Alex Gino

I think I’m going to love this book because it reminds me so much of Wonder, another children’s book also about acceptance. Hope you’ll join us! We’ll be discussing it on October 29th.

 

We’ve had a great run with our book club and may start it up again if things slow down in our lives. This will be our 10th book and we think it will be an awesome final book. Thanks for joining us!

And don’t forget, next week we’ll be discussing The Silver Linings Playbook on September 24th.

Page Turners book club by Expandng & DIY Mama

The Princess Bride (Discussion)

I’m so excited to discuss The Princess Bride with you today. I can recite the entire movie and have listened to the book several times but had never read the book. Lisa and I wanted to choose a fun read for August since everyone is so busy with back to school (and in my case, moving) so I loved having this mandatory fun reading time to unwind.  If I could give the book a 6/5 I would. I loved the story tellers voice as well as the playful characters throughout the story.

I have 3 questions below, and Lisa’s got 3 over on her blog. Feel free to discuss any or all of the questions in the comment section or link-up your post at the bottom. Lisa and I are sharing the same link-up, so you don’t have to enter on both blogs. The linky will close in a week. Alright, let’s get started!

2015-PageTurners-08PrincessBride1

And now, for the discussion. Before I begin, I’ll remind you that there will be spoilers ahead.

1. Who is your favorite character? This is a tough question that I thought about for days because I knew I wanted to only choose one (unlike my fav Harry Potter characters of which I have two for each gender). For The Princess Bride, I chose Fezzik as my favorite character. I love his big kind heart and how excited he gets at simple pleasures (like the rhyming game or when Wesley shakes his head at the castle wall). He seems like such a great companion on an adventure like this. Just so you know, my runners up were Wesley and then Miracle Max.

2. Have you seen the movie? Do you think the movie lives up to the book? I have seen the movie at least 20 times. I had a poster of Wesley and Buttercup kissing (the best kiss in history) in my college room as well as a tshirt that I wore out. I attempted to be Buttercup for Halloween one year but fell quite short of her beauty. I think the movie is a perfect adaptation of the book. They chose just the right parts to cut and the right parts to embellish. They emphasized the character’s quick wits which is my favorite part of the book. It’s the perfect action/adventure/love story and will be my favorite movie for years to come.

3. When we first meet Inigo and Fezzik, they are working with Vizzini to kidnap Buttercup. Later, they become allies of Westley in his efforts to rescue her. What causes Inigo and Fezzik to change . . . or do they really change at all over the course of the novel? I don’t believe they changed. I think their hearts were always in the right place (Inigo doing anything he could to revenge his father and Fezzik being taken in by people who cares about him). Although they started out as thieves and kidnappers, I don’t think they were every ‘bad guys’.

2015-PageTurners-08PrincessBride2

Now, it’s your turn! Answer my questions, ask your own, or start your own discussions. I’ll be responding to comments in the comment section, and you’ll get an email when I (or anyone else) does so. Or, link-up a blog post with your review and/or the answers to these questions. Also be sure to check out Lisa’s discussion questions on her blog. We’re sharing the same linky, so no need to link-up on both blogs.

Remember our September selection is The Silver Linings Playbook. We’ll be discussing it on September 24th.

Page Turners book club by Expandng & DIY Mama

If you’d like to see some of our favorite books, head over to our Page Turners Pinterest board!

Follow Shelly @ DIY Mama’s board Book Club on Pinterest.

Page Turners Book Selection: September

This post contains affiliate links for Amazon Associates.
School’s starting for a lot of you out there! Are you slowing down or getting more busy now? Think you’ll have time to hit the books with your kids? If you’re looking for something to read and discuss with a group, hope you’ll join us in September for:

Silver Linings Playbook- Page Turners Book Club

The Silver Linings Playbook by Matthew Quick

I loved everything about the movie The Silver Linings Playbook. Bradley Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence are two of my favorite actors and I’m a bit obsessed with any movie that includes dancing. As soon as I saw the movie I knew I needed to read the book to understand the characters more deeply. I’m excited to see how it differs from the movie.

Silver Linings Playbook

Hope you’ll join us! We’ll be discussing it on September 24th.

And don’t forget, this month we’ll be discussing The Princess Bride on August 28th.
Page Turners book club by Expandng & DIY Mama

 
Subscribe!Facebook!Twitter!Email!Pinterest!Bloglovin!Instagram!Image Map

If you’re on Pinterest, check out our Book Club board with our favorite books. We’re open to book suggestions as well!
Follow Shelly @ DIY Mama’s board Book Club on Pinterest.

Google+